Communication and pragmatic peculiarities of esoteric forecasts in mass media discourse of the Russo-Ukrainian war
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.28925/2311-259x.2023.2.9Keywords:
media discourse, critical discourse analysis, forecasting, esoteric forecasting, linguistic influence, communicative strategies, modalityAbstract
The subject of the study is esoteric projections as one of the ways to create a verbal pattern of the future. The study is based on the text and video content containing esoteric forecasts, fortune telling and predictions about the course of the Russo-Ukrainian War after the full-scale invasion of Ukraine by the aggressor’s military. Today Ukrainians suffer from the Russian military’s criminal actions and information warfare organized by the authorities and propagandists of the Russian Federation, they feel permanent stress and are very sensitive to esoteric content that creates an illusion of understanding of the situation, provokes wrong conclusions and actions, which can result in dangerous situations for the citizens. Thus, Ukraine has a serious problem of differentiating between high-quality and manipulative forecasts, which makes urgent the study of its communication and pragmatic peculiarities, verification of the forecasts, and dissemination of information about forecasting content quality. The aim of the study is to accentuate and explore esoteric forecasting as a special type of verbal modeling of the future, which has different communication purposes, specific intentionally organized non-verbal context of the messages about the future and means of linguistic impact on the recipient, as opposed to the scientific and naive empirical forecasting.
The results of this study showed a manipulative nature of the esoteric forecasts — in most cases, they are aimed at attracting an audience to the media channels with corresponding content and forming a social and political opinion beneficial to the sponsors of such content, or required evaluation of the events in Ukraine and other countries. From the linguistic point of view, esoteric forecasts are typically characterized by imperative constructions with the explicitly realized epistemic modality of reality expressed by the modes of faith, knowledge, and belief. This is a distinct feature of the forecasts based on analysis, whereas scientific and naive empirical forecasting is characterized by the author’s uncertainty about the forecasting content, which they demonstrate using constructions with hypothetic epistemic modality and lexical means that convey uncertainty and hesitation.
This study is novel as linguistic and extralingual means of expression of esoteric forecasts under the conditions of the Russo-Ukrainian War were analysed for the first time. It is worth studying scientific and empirical forecasts and determine the nature of their influence on the media content consumers in the future.
Downloads
References
Arutyunova, N. (1988). Tipy yazykovykh znacheniy: Otsenka. Sobytie. Fakt [Types of language values: Evaluation. Event. Fact]. Nauka.
Arutyunova, N., Bulygina, T., Kibrik, A., Krasukhin, K., Krylov, S., Paducheva, Ye., Radzievskaya, T., & Shmelev, A. (1992). Chelovecheskiy faktor v yazyke. Kommunikatsiya, modalnost, deyksis [The human factor in language. Communication, modality, deixis]. Nauka.
Besperstova, O., & Sukhoi, O. (2023, January 21) “Naprykintsi lita rosiiany mozhut navazhytysia nafinalnu sprobu vziattia Kyieva”, — amerykanskyi viiskovyi ekspert Fillip Karber [“At the end of the summer, the Russians may dare to make a final attempt to capture Kyiv,” — American military expert Phillip Karber]. Fakty. https://fakty.ua/414013-v-konce-leta-rossiyane-mogut-reshitsya-na-finalnuyu-popytku-vzyatiya-kieva---amerikanskij-voennyj-ekspert-fillip-karber
Chadiuk, M. (2019). Zasoby vtilennia implitsytnoi informatsii v novynnykh zaholovkakh [Means of implicit information implementation in news headlines]. Scientific notes of NAUKMA. Linguistics, 2, 36–43. https://doi.org/10.18523/2616-8502.2019.2.36-43
Cherkhava, O. (2011). Anhlomovne bibliine prorotstvo yak riznovyd fideistychnoho dyskursu (na materiali KING JAMES BIBLE) [English-language biblical prophecy as a type of fideistic discourse (based on the KING JAMES BIBLE material)] (Thesis of PhD dissertation, Odesa Mechnikov National University).
Dotsenko, O. (2006). Semantyko-prahmatychnyi syntaksys: osoblyvosti vyrazhennia modalnosti [Semantic-pragmatic syntax: features of modality expression]. Millennium.
Ekstrasens Roman Sheptytskyi. (2023). Vazhlyva pravda pro Pidryv Kakhovskoi HES! Yaki teper budut naslidky dlia pryrody i ZAES? [The important truth about the Undermining of Kakhovska HPP! What will be the consequences for nature and the ZPP?] [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UuZOzrVkCw
Fakty ICTV. (2023, June 10). Danilov: MY ZNALY pro plany rosiian PIDIRVATY Kakhovsku HES, ale… [Danilov: WE KNEW about the Russians’ plans to BLOW UP the Kakhovska HPP, but…] [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNt5S-k5WS8
Halona, N. (2013). Struktura i semantyka hipotetychnoho modusu [The structure and semantics of the hypothetical mode]. In Aktualni problemy leksykolohii i hramatyky ukrainskoi movy (pp. 252–274). NPU im. M. P. Drahomanova.
Horbatenko, V. (2004). “Analiz maibutnoho” ta yoho rol v upravlinni sotsialno-politychnymy protsesamy [“Analysis of the future” and its role in the management of socio-political processes]. Politychnyi menedzhment, 1, 30–40.
Horodianenko, V. (Ed.) (2003). Sotsiolohiia: pidruchnyk [Sociology: Textbook]. Akademiya.
Ihina, Z. (2009). Modalni slova u personazhnomu movlenni: semantychnyi ta prahmatychnyi aspekty (na materiali prozy anhliiskoho y amerykanskoho modernizmu [Modal words in character speech: semantic and pragmatic aspects (based on the material of English and American modernism prose)] (Thesis of PhD dissertation, Kyiv National Linguistic University).
Komm, Ya. (1990). Funktsionirovanie vyskazyvaniy s eksplitsitnym modusom mneniya [Functioning of statements with an explicit mode of opinion]. Tajik State Technical University.
Kozlovskyi, V. (1991). Pro prahmatychnu spriamovanist subiektyvno-otsinnoho aspektu modalnosti [About the pragmatic focus of the subjective-evaluative aspect of modality]. Linguistics, 3, 68–73.
Lanochka Aleksandrova. (2023). Kakhovska HES!!! Shcho bude iz Zaporizkoiu AES: svizha informatsiia vid Taro! [Kakhovska HPP!!! What will happen to the Zaporizhzhya NPP: fresh information from Taro!] [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TFY9salPPYs
Naumuk, O. (2010). Kohnityvni ta prahmatychni kharakterystyky porad u suchasnii anhliiskii movi [Cognitive and pragmatic features of advice in modern English] (Thesis of PhD dissertation, Donetsk National University).
Prysedska, V. (2008). Struktura, semantyka i prahmatyka anhliiskykh, nimetskykh, rosiiskykh ta ukrainskykh publichnykh pokazhchykiv [The structure, semantics, and pragmatics of English, German, Russian, and Ukrainian public indexes] (Thesis of PhD dissertation, Donetsk National University).
Skybytska, N. (2004). Epistemichna modalnist v anhliiskii movi (diakhronnyi aspekt) [Epistemic modality in English (diachronic aspect)] (Thesis of PhD dissertation, Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv).
Sydorenko, O. (Ed.) (2010). Filosofiia: pidruchnyk [Philosophy: Textbook]. Znannia.
Taro Olenka. (2023). Karty na sohodni dlia Vas i dlia Ukrainy [Today’s cards for you and for Ukraine Tarot analysis by Olenka from Canada] [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shSRlSvIxoc
TSN. (2023, June 10). Ekstrasens Maks Hordieiev: Pidstupni plany rosiian, dolia Pivdnia ta khto nakazav pidirvaty Kakhovsku HES [Psychic Max Gordeev: The insidious plans of the Russians, the fate of the South and who ordered to blow up the Kakhovska HPP] [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7oUUzsB0-Og
Zubchenko, Ya. (2022, April 9). Mars u fazi “zakryi rota”. Chomu astroloham u novynakh krashche pomovchaty [Mars is in the “shut up” phase. Why it is better for astrologers to remain silent in the news]. Media Detector. https://detector.media/infospace/article/198212/2022-04-09-mars-u-fazi-zakryy-rota-chomu-astrologam-u-novynakh-krashche-pomovchaty
Zubchenko, Ya. (2023, January 14). Doshka hanby. Media, yaki publikuiut astrolohiv [The board of shame. Media outlets that publish astrologers]. Media Detector. https://detector.media/kritika/article/207011/2023-01-14-doshka-ganby-media-yaki-publikuyut-astrologiv
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Olena Dotsenko
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).