Feminism and communism: specifics of interaction in the western Ukrainian media discourse of the 1920s – 1930s

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.28925/2311-259x.2020.3.4

Keywords:

communist magazine, feminism, ideology, gender discrimination

Abstract

The Subject of the Study is the models of interaction and intersection of ideologies in media discourse. In contrast to the homogeneous ideological discourse of the Soviet press, the Western Ukrainian of the interwar period was ideologically diverse, in particular, “leftist” ideas were propagated in magazines. There is a noticeable trend in modern media studies: researchers to some extent ignore the “communist segment” of the Western Ukrainian press of the interwar period, this is due to the relevance of our study. Realizing that the communist movement was not widespread in Western Ukraine during the interwar period, let us consider the press of communist organizations both for the sake of objectivity and the need to explore models of the intersection of communist ideology and feminism and this is the novelty of the research. The aim of the article is to investigate the specifics of the interaction of feminism and communism in the Western Ukrainian media discourse of the 1920s and 1930s on the material of communist magazines. The weekly Nasha Zemlya and Sel-Rob, which represented the communist ideological discourse of Western Ukraine, were selected for analysis. The research methodology is a combination of critical discourse analysis with feminist critique. The Results of the Study. Communist magazines were concerned about how to attract Ukrainian women to the party ranks. The key issues covered in Western Ukrainian communist magazines were: women’s unemployment, low-skilled workers, difficult conditions, and low wages. At the same time, only women journalists paid attention to the gender aspect of such problems, for example, the gender disparity in the remuneration of men and women. The political and ideological orientation of Western Ukrainian communist newspapers toward the Soviet Union and Moscow Bolshevism was obvious. Propaganda materials about the Soviet Union’s success in resolving the “women’s issue” regularly appeared in the newspapers of Western Ukrainian communists. Publications on women’s issues were feminist in terms of authorial Intentions, ideological accents, and interpretation of facts. However, discrimination against women was primarily due to an unjust socio-economic system. Despite feminist intentions in the materials of communist magazines, activists of the Ukrainian Women’s Union were criticized as the main ideological competitors in the struggle for the Ukrainian woman.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Olha Khamedova, Borys Grinchenko Kyiv University, Institute of Journalism

PhD in Philology, Associate Professor of Department of Journalism and New Media

References

Bohachevska-Khomiak, М. (1995). Bilym po bilomu. Zhinky v hromadskomu zhytti Ukrainy. 1884–1939. [White on white. Women in the public life of Ukraine. 18841939]. Kyiv: Lybid’.

Deshcho pro “oborontsiv” ta “opikuniv” pratsiuiuchykh zhinok [Something about “defenders” and “guardians” of working women]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 9 November, 208, 3.

Fashysty propoviduiut [The Fascists preach]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 7 September, 201, 4.

Gabor, V.  (1997). Transcarpathian Ukrainian-language press of the 20-30th years of the twentieth century in the context of the national revival of the region. (PhD diss. (journ.sci), Institute of Journalism, Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Kyiv).

Gill, R. (2009). Mediated intimacy and postfeminism: a discourse analytic examination of sex and relationships advice in a women’s magazine. Discourse & Communication, 3(4), 345–369. https://doi.org/10.1177/1750481309343870.

Klushina, N. (2014). Intentsionalnost (Intentionality). Effektivnoe rechevoe obschenie (bazovyie kompetentsii). Slovar-spravochnik. Elektronnoe izdanie. (pp. 190-191). Krasnoyarsk: Sibirskiy federalnyiy universitet.

Kollontay, A. (1919). Novaya moral i rabochiy klass [New morals and the working class]. Moskva: Izd-vo VTsIK Sovetov RK i K. Deputatov.

Kolontay, A. (1918). Robitnytsia Maty [Mother Worker]. Cleveland: Vydanie Ukrainskoi Federatsii Amerykanskoi Sotsialistychnoi Partii.

Kost’, S. (2008). Istoriia ukrainskoi zhurnalistyky (zakhidnoukrainska presa pershoi polovyny ХХ st.: ideino-kontseptualni zasady, periodyzatsiia). [History of Ukrainian journalism (Western Ukrainian press of the first half of the twentieth century: ideological and conceptual principles, periodization)]. Lviv.

Lazar, M. (2007). Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Articulating a feminist discourse praxes. Critical Discourse Studies, 4(2). https://doi.org/10.1080/17405900701464816.

Matison, D. (2017).  Media-diskurs. Analiz media-tekstov. Issledovaniya media i kul’tury [Media discourse. Analysis of media texts. Media and culture research]. (O. Gritchina, Trans). Kharkov: Izd-vo “Gumanitarnyi Centr”.

Mizhnarodnyi den robitnytsi, [International Workers’ Day]. (1930). Sel-Rob, 9 March, 82, 1.

Panchuk, M. (2011). Komunistychna partiia Zakhidnoi Ukrainy [Communist Party of the Western Ukraine]. Entsyklopediia istorii Ukrainy. T. 9. (p. 507–509). Kyiv: Naukova dumka, 2011.

Pavliuk, I. (2001). Ukrainska lehalna presa Volyni, Polissia, Kholmshchyny ta Pidliashshia 1917–1939, 1941–1944 rr. [Ukrainian legal press Volin, Polissya, Kholmshchyna and Pidlyashya 19171939, 19411944]. Lviv: Kameniar.

Pereklychka dvokh spilnykiv [Roll call of two spilniks]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 5 January, 166167, 1.

Pratsiuiuche zhinotstvo v riady orhanizatsii [Working women in the ranks of organizations]. (1930).  Sel’-Rob, 9 November, 208, 3.

Pratsiuiuche zhinotstvo y bezrobittia [Working women and unemployment]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 9 March, 208, 2.

Pratsiuiuchi zhinky i viina [Working women and war]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 9 March, 208, 2.

Pro ekonomichne polozhennia pratsiuiuchoi molodi [On the economic situation of working youth]. (1931). Nasha zemlya, 13 September, 18(25), 3.

Pro pratsiuiuchu zhinku [Аbout a working woman], (1931). Nasha zemlia, 26 Julay, 13(20), 3.

Prohram i organizatsiinyi statut Ukrainskoi Seliansko-Robitnychoi Sotsiialistychnoi Yednosty Sel-Rob Yednist [Programs and organizational charter of the Ukrainian Peasants 'and Workers' Socialist Unity “Sel-Rob Unity”]. (1928). L’viv.

Romanyuk, M. (1996). Ukrainska presa Pivnichnoi Bukovyny (1918–1940) [Ukrainian Press of Northern Bukovina (1918–1940)]. Lviv: Feniks.

Roza Liuksemburh (v 11-ti rokovyny heroiskoi smerti) [Rosa Luxemburg (on the 11th anniversary of her heroic death)]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 19 January, 170, 3.

Shapoval, Yu. (1999). Dilo (1880–1939 rr.): Postup ukrainskoi suspilnoi dumky [Case” (18801939): The progress of Ukrainian public opinion]. L’viv.

Shcho bachyla chesko-slovatska delehatsiia v Radianskomu Soiuzi? [What did the Czech-Slovak delegation see in the Soviet Union?]. (1931). Nasha zemlya, 13 December, 29(36), 3.

Snitsarchuk, L. (2009). Ukrainska presa Halychyny (1919–1939 rr.) i zhurnalistykoznavchyi dyskurs [Ukrainian press of Galicia (1919–1939) and journalistic discourse]. Lviv: LNNBU im. V. Stefanyka.

Tycher, S., Meier, M., Vodak, R. Metody teksta i diskurs-analiza [Methods of text and discourse analysis]. Khar’kov: Humanytarnyi Tsentr.

Voronina, M. (2017). “Nova radianska zhinka”: henderna polityka radianskoi vlady [“The New Soviet Woman”: Gender Politics of Soviet Power]. Ukrainski zhinky u hornyli modernizatsii (pp. 131–156). Kharkiv: Klub simeinoho dozvillia.

Voronina, M. (2017). Bilshovytskyi emansypatsiinyi eksperyment u 1920-kh rokakh [Bolshevik emancipation experiment in the 1920s]. Ukrainski zhinky u hornyli modernizatsii (pp. 106–131). Kharkiv: Klub simeinoho dozvillia.

Yak zhyvut robitnytsi v Yaponii [How do workers live in Japan]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 26 October, 206, 2.

Yak zhyvut zhinky. Boryslav [How women live. Boryslav]. (1930). Sel’-Rob, 19 January, 170, 4.

Zavdannia ukrainskoi selianky pid teperishniu khvyliu [The task of the Ukrainian peasant at the present stage]. (1930). Zhinocha Dolya, 32–34, 6.

Zhyvotko, A. (1999). Istoriia ukrainskoi presy. [The history of the Ukrainian press]. Kyiv: Naukovo-vydavnychyi tsentr: “Nasha kultura i nauka”.

Downloads


Abstract views: 422

Published

31.10.2020

How to Cite

Khamedova, O. (2020). Feminism and communism: specifics of interaction in the western Ukrainian media discourse of the 1920s – 1930s . Synopsis: Text, Context, Media, 26(3), 98–107. https://doi.org/10.28925/2311-259x.2020.3.4

Issue

Section

Media and virtual reality